Summary
Cash accounting records income when money arrives and expenses when they're paid; accrual accounting records them when they're earned or incurred. For income tax, the CRA lets only farmers, fishers and self-employed commission agents use the cash method; every other Ontario business reports on an accrual basis, and GST/HST is generally due when you invoice. Lenders and investors also expect accrual statements. This guide explains both methods, shows how they can produce very different profits, and includes a calculator to compare them.
Ask an Ontario small business owner how the business did last month and most will check the bank balance. That's cash thinking: money in, money out. It's intuitive and it matters, but it can also mislead. A large customer payment can make a weak month look strong, and a big invoice not yet paid can make a strong month look weak.
Accrual accounting fixes that by matching income and expenses to the period they belong to. It's also what the CRA requires for most businesses, what lenders expect in financial statements, and what makes GST/HST filings line up with your books.
Knowing the difference helps you read your numbers correctly and avoid tax surprises. Ledgerive's bookkeeping services keep Ontario businesses on accurate monthly accrual books, while still showing owners the cash picture they need day to day.
Not sure which method your books use?
Get a free review of your bookkeeping setup and a plan to move to accurate monthly accrual books. Book a free 30-minute call.
1. Cash vs Accrual: The Basics
| Feature | Cash basis | Accrual basis |
|---|---|---|
| Income recorded | When money is received | When it is earned (usually when invoiced) |
| Expenses recorded | When they are paid | When they are incurred |
| Receivables and payables | Not tracked in profit | Tracked on the balance sheet |
| Inventory | Generally ignored | Counted and valued each period |
| Prepaid expenses and deposits | Expensed when paid | Spread over the period they cover |
| Simplicity | Very simple | More work, but more accurate |
| Who uses it | Farmers, fishers, commission agents; internal cash tracking | Most Ontario businesses, corporations, lenders, investors |
2. What the CRA Requires
The CRA is clear: farmers, fishers and self-employed commission agents can choose the cash or accrual method to report income, and all other self-employment income must be reported using the accrual method. Corporations also report on an accrual basis.
- Accrual income: report income in the fiscal period you earn it, no matter when you receive it.
- Accrual expenses: deduct expenses in the period you incur them, whether or not you've paid them.
- Inventory: must be valued at the end of each fiscal period under the accrual method.
- Capital purchases: under either method, equipment and vehicles are generally claimed through capital cost allowance, not expensed when paid.
In practice, this means a sole proprietor running a cleaning company in Mississauga or a consulting practice in Ottawa can't simply report bank deposits as income; unpaid invoices at year-end count too.
3. A Worked Example
Consider an Ontario contractor that invoiced $900,000 of work this year and incurred $780,000 of costs. It started the year with $60,000 owing from customers and ended with $150,000, and its unpaid bills rose from $40,000 to $70,000.
On an accrual basis, the business earned $120,000. On a cash basis it shows only $60,000, because $90,000 more is now owed by customers while it owes suppliers $30,000 more. For tax, the CRA expects the $120,000 figure. For managing cash, the owner needs to know the $60,000 figure too. Good bookkeeping shows both.
4. GST/HST Timing and Accrual
Even businesses that think in cash need to handle HST on an accrual-like basis. GST/HST generally becomes collectible on the earlier of the day the customer pays and the day the invoice is issued or payment is due.
- Invoice in March, paid in May: the HST generally belongs in the reporting period that includes March.
- Deposits: HST is generally collectible when a deposit is applied as payment, so watch large customer deposits.
- Input tax credits: generally claimed for the period in which the tax on purchases becomes payable, with documentation.
- Cash impact: a business with large receivables may owe HST on invoices it hasn't been paid for yet, so budget for it.
- Quick method: some small businesses can use the quick method to simplify remittances; it changes how much HST you remit, not when sales are recorded.
5. Interactive Cash vs Accrual Profit Calculator
Enter a year's figures to compare accrual profit with cash profit and see what drives the difference. Results are illustrative and exclude inventory, capital purchases and tax.
6. What Lenders, Investors and Buyers Expect
Banks, BDC, CSBFP lenders and investors read accrual financial statements. They want to see revenue matched to the period it was earned, receivables and payables on the balance sheet, and margins that aren't distorted by the timing of payments.
- Loan applications: projections and historical statements should be on the same accrual basis; see our guides to the CSBFP loan business plan in Canada and the use of funds and repayment sections of a loan application.
- Covenants: ratios such as debt service coverage are calculated from accrual statements.
- Valuation: buyers value normalized accrual earnings, and cash-basis books need to be restated first.
- Document readiness: our guide to preparing your documents before a business plan lists the statements lenders ask for.
7. When Cash Tracking Still Helps
Accrual books don't replace cash management; they complement it. Owners still need a clear view of cash.
| Question | Best view |
|---|---|
| Was the business profitable last month? | Accrual income statement |
| Can we make payroll next Friday? | Cash forecast |
| Which customers or jobs make money? | Accrual, by customer or job |
| How much HST do we owe this quarter? | Accrual (invoices issued) |
| Do we need a line of credit? | 13-week cash forecast |
Growing businesses often find that the gap between accrual profit and cash becomes the main management issue; that's one of the signs covered in our guide to when a Brampton business needs a fractional CFO. Trucking firms feel it acutely with 30- to 60-day shipper terms, as our fractional CFO guide for trucking and logistics explains.
8. Switching Methods and BN Registration
- Cash to accrual for tax: request permission in writing from your CRA tax services office before the filing deadline, explaining why.
- Accrual to cash (where allowed): include a statement showing each adjustment to income and expenses.
- For your books: set opening receivables, payables, inventory and prepaid balances, then record transactions on an accrual basis going forward.
- BN registration: make sure your nine-digit business number and its GST/HST, payroll and income tax accounts are set up correctly, so filings match the method in your books.
- Incorporating: a new corporation gets its own CRA business number and reports on an accrual basis from day one.
Once your books are on an accrual basis, our financial modeling services and fractional CFO services can build forecasts that bridge accrual profit and cash, and our business plan services use them for financing.
9. Common Mistakes Ontario Owners Make
- Reporting bank deposits as income and missing unpaid invoices at year-end.
- Expensing annual insurance or software all at once instead of over the period it covers.
- Ignoring inventory, which distorts cost of goods sold and gross margin.
- Filing HST on cash received instead of invoices issued, creating mismatches with the CRA.
- Treating customer deposits as income before the work is done.
- Using cash-basis statements for a loan, forcing a last-minute restatement before the lender will review them.
10. Frequently Asked Questions
Can a small business use cash basis accounting in Canada?
For income tax, the CRA allows only farmers, fishers and self-employed commission agents to choose the cash method. All other self-employment and business income must be reported using the accrual method. Incorporated businesses also report on an accrual basis. A business can still track cash internally, but tax reporting must follow the required method.
What is the difference between cash and accrual accounting?
Cash accounting records income when money is received and expenses when they are paid. Accrual accounting records income when it is earned and expenses when they are incurred, regardless of when cash moves, so it includes receivables, payables, inventory and prepaid expenses and gives a truer picture of profit for each period.
Do I report GST/HST on a cash or accrual basis?
GST/HST generally becomes collectible on the earlier of the day the customer pays and the day the invoice is issued or payment is due, so most businesses report HST on invoices in the period they are issued, even if the customer hasn't paid yet. Input tax credits are generally claimed for the period in which the purchase tax becomes payable.
Can I keep my books on a cash basis and file taxes on accrual?
Many very small businesses track day-to-day activity on a cash basis and have their accountant convert to accrual at year-end by adding receivables, payables, inventory and prepaid amounts. It works for simple businesses, but monthly accrual books give better management information and make the year-end conversion unnecessary.
How do I switch from cash to accrual accounting?
For tax purposes, moving from the cash method to the accrual method requires permission from your CRA tax services office, requested in writing before the filing deadline with your reasons. Moving from accrual to cash, where allowed, requires a statement showing the adjustments. For your books, an accountant can set opening receivables, payables and inventory balances to make the change.
Summary
Most Ontario small businesses must report income on an accrual basis; only farmers, fishers and self-employed commission agents may choose the cash method for tax. GST/HST is generally collectible when you invoice, and lenders expect accrual statements. Keep accrual books with your CRA business number accounts set up correctly, and pair them with a cash forecast so you see both your true profit and the cash you have to run the business.
Get books that show your real profit
Ledgerive keeps accrual-basis books, HST filings and monthly reports for small businesses across Ontario. Book a free 30-minute call or reach us directly.
Sources: Canada Revenue Agency, Accounting methods. GST/HST summaries are general; examples and calculator results are illustrative. Confirm your situation with a qualified tax professional.